Contingencies and Provisions: Recognition and Measurement

Accounting for contingencies and provisions can be complex. Many accountants struggle with recognizing and measuring these uncertain items.

This article provides a comprehensive guide to accounting for contingencies and provisions under IAS 37. You will learn the key concepts, recognition criteria, measurement approaches, and disclosure requirements.

We cover defining contingent liabilities and assets, provision examples, types of contingencies, as well as summary checklists. Read on to master this challenging area of accounting.

Introduction to Accounting for Contingencies and Provisions

This section provides an overview of contingencies and provisions in accounting, including key definitions, recognition criteria, and measurement approaches according to IAS 37.

Defining Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets

A contingent liability is a possible obligation that arises from past events and whose existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within the control of the entity. For example, a company may face a lawsuit, where the outcome is uncertain and could result in a future cash outflow if the verdict goes against the company.

In contrast, a contingent asset is a possible asset that arises from past events and whose existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within the control of the entity. An example is a company initiating a legal claim, where a positive ruling could result in a cash inflow, but the outcome is not certain.

Recognition Criteria for Provisions under IAS 37

To recognize a provision on the balance sheet according to IAS 37, all of the following criteria must be met:

• There is a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event
• It is probable (more likely than not) that an outflow of resources will be required to settle the obligation
• A reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation

If these conditions are not met, no provision can be recognized.

Measuring Provisions: Best Estimates and Present Value

Provisions are measured at the best estimate of the expenditure required to settle the present obligation at the end of the reporting period. The estimate should reflect the inherent risks and uncertainties, taking into account all available evidence, experience, and (if applicable) the opinions of experts.

Where the effect of the time value of money is material, the provision is measured at the present value of the expected expenditures required to settle the obligation using a pre-tax discount rate. This increases the provision's accuracy.

IAS 37 Provisions Examples in Practice

An example is a pending lawsuit where legal precedent indicates the company is likely to lose. The company would recognize a provision equal to the best estimate of the costs of settling the lawsuit, such as legal fees, damages, and penalties. Adjustments to the provision would be made as new evidence emerges, with increases treated as expenses in profit or loss.

Another example involves decommissioning obligations in industries like oil and gas. Companies estimate future removal and restoration costs of drilling sites, adjust for inflation assumptions, and discount the provision to present value. This is then capitalized as part of exploration assets.

How do you recognize provision in accounting?

An entity recognizes a provision if it is probable (more likely than not) that there will be an outflow of economic resources to settle an obligation. Some key points on recognizing provisions under IAS 37:

• There must be a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event in order to recognize a provision. This means it is a liability of uncertain timing or amount.
• The obligation must result in a probable outflow of resources to settle it. If the outflow is not probable, it is disclosed as a contingent liability instead.
• Provisions are measured at the best estimate of the amount required to settle the obligation. This is typically based on past experience, forecasts, and the risks involved.
• Provisions should be reviewed at each balance sheet date and adjusted to reflect the current best estimate of the liability.
• Common examples of provisions include warranties, legal disputes, environmental restoration and decommissioning costs.

So in summary - recognition of a provision requires identifying a present obligation, assessing the probability of an outflow to settle it, and estimating the amount of that outflow. Contingent liabilities are disclosed but not recognized unless an outflow becomes probable.

What are the provisions and contingencies in accounting?

Provisions are liabilities of uncertain timing or amount that arise from past events and are recognized on the balance sheet when:

• There is a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event
• It is probable that an outflow of resources will be required to settle the obligation
• A reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation

Some examples of provisions include warranties, legal disputes, environmental restoration and decommissioning costs.

Contingencies refer to possible obligations that arise from past events and whose existence will be confirmed only by uncertain future events not wholly within the control of the entity. Contingent liabilities are not recognized on the balance sheet but are disclosed in the notes to the financial statements when their occurrence is probable.

Examples of contingent liabilities include pending litigation where the outcome is uncertain, claims against the company that are being disputed, and guarantees of indebtedness of others.

The key difference between provisions and contingencies is that provisions are recorded as liabilities, while contingencies are not recorded, but may need to be disclosed. Determining whether a future obligation should be accounted for as a provision or contingency requires judgment in assessing the probability and reliability of measurement of any potential outflows.

What is the accounting treatment for contingencies?

A contingency arises when there is uncertainty regarding a future event that could result in a gain or loss. As per IAS 37, contingencies are not recognized in the financial statements. However, adequate disclosure is required for material contingencies.

The key considerations in accounting for contingencies are:

• Recognition - A provision is recognized only when there is a present obligation from a past event, payment is probable, and the amount can be estimated reliably. If these conditions are not met, no provision is recognized.

• Measurement - The best estimate of the expenditure required to settle the obligation is the amount that an entity would rationally pay to settle or transfer the obligation. This represents the present value of expenditures required.

• Disclosure - Even in cases where no provision is recognized because either a payment is not probable or the amount cannot be estimated reliably, the nature of the contingency and an estimate of its potential financial impact should be disclosed.

For example, pending litigation against a company is a contingency. If management determines that it is probable the claim will succeed and a reliable estimate of the amount can be made, a provision is recognized. If not probable or a reliable estimate cannot be made, no provision is recognized but details of the litigation are disclosed as a contingent liability.

The key is to recognize provisions only when stringent recognition criteria are met, while disclosing details of material contingencies even if no provision is recognized. This enables users to assess the potential impact of contingencies on the company's financial position.

sbb-itb-beb59a9

When should a contingent asset be Recognised?

A contingent asset becomes a realized asset recordable on the balance sheet when the realization of cash flows associated with it becomes relatively certain. In this case, the asset is recognized in the period when the change in status occurs.

Contingent assets may arise due to the economic value being unknown. Some examples include:

• A company is involved in a court case that may result in the award of damages in its favor. Those damages are a contingent asset, as their receipt is not virtually certain.
• A company sells a product with a warranty under which customers are covered for certain production defects. The expected recoveries under the warranty cover are a contingent asset, as the amount the company will actually receive is not yet known.

In general, contingent assets are not recorded in the financial statements since their realization is uncertain. However, they may be disclosed in the notes to the accounts if their conversion to actual assets is likely.

If the realization of a contingent asset becomes virtually certain, then it is no longer a contingent asset and instead becomes an actual asset. For example, if the company wins the court case and the damages are awarded, the contingent asset is realized because the company will receive the cash. At that point, the company should recognize the damages on its balance sheet.

The value recorded for a realized contingent asset is the best estimate of the cash flows expected from it. This is often the present value of the expected cash inflows. Uncertainties surrounding the amounts and timing still need to be considered. As cash is received, the asset will be reduced accordingly.

In summary, a contingent asset is recognized on the balance sheet when it transitions from being a possibility to an asset whose receipt is virtually certain. The value recorded should be management's best estimate of the ultimately realizable amount.

Understanding IAS 37: Provisions, Contingent Liabilities, and Contingent Assets

IAS 37 outlines the accounting treatment and disclosures required for provisions, contingent liabilities, and contingent assets. This section will provide clarity on recognizing and measuring these items appropriately.

IAS 37 PDF: A Comprehensive Overview

Here is a summarized explanation of key aspects covered in IAS 37 (full IAS 37 PDF document can be downloaded here):

• Provisions are liabilities with uncertain timing or amount. Recognize provisions when: 1) There is a legal or constructive obligation from a past event, 2) It is probable there will be an outflow of resources, 3) The amount can be reliably estimated. Measure at best estimate of cash outflow required.
• Contingent liabilities are possible obligations dependent on uncertain future events, or present obligations not recognized as likely/reliably measurable. Disclose details unless economic outflow is remote.
• Contingent assets are possible assets arising from past events and confirmed only on occurrence of uncertain future events. Disclose details where inflows are probable.

Key principles are prudent recognition of provisions/liabilities based on realistic estimates, and transparent disclosures.

IAS 37 Questions and Answers PDF

Some common IAS 37 questions and detailed answers can be found in this IAS 37 Q&A PDF. It covers issues like:

• When to recognize provisions versus contingent liabilities
• Measurement of provisions - best estimate versus probability-weighted amounts
• Changes in provisions due to new information/remeasurements
• Discounting provisions to present value
• Onerous contracts and restructuring provisions

Contingent Liabilities: Recognition and Disclosure

Contingent liabilities are:

• Possible obligations arising from past events, not recognized as provisions due to low probability or unreliable estimates
• Present obligations not meeting provision criteria due to uncertainty or inability to measure reliably

Disclosure is required unless economic outflows are remote. Details should cover nature of contingency, uncertainties, and financial effects if possible.

Recognition happens when reliable estimates become available and/or outflows become probable. Recognize as provisions at best estimates per IAS 37.

Contingent Assets: Recognition and Disclosure

Contingent assets are possible assets arising from past events, only confirmed by future uncertain events.

Disclosure is required where inflows are probable. Details should cover the asset's nature and estimated financial impact.

Recognition only happens when asset realization is virtually certain. Recognize related income/asset accordingly.

Prudence usually prevents contingent asset recognition unless realization is near-certain.

Types of Contingencies and Provisions

This section covers several common types of contingencies and provisions encountered under IAS 37, including warranties, legal disputes, environmental restoration, and restructuring.

Product Warranty Provisions: A Case Study

Under IAS 37, companies must recognize provisions for the future costs of warranties given on products sold during the current period. To estimate the warranty provision, companies should:

• Review historical warranty data to estimate future claims
• Consider the nature and duration of warranties
• Update estimates each period to reflect new information

For example, a manufacturer provides all customers a standard 12-month product warranty. Based on past experience, it expects warranty claims of 3% of annual sales, with an average claim cost of $100. If last year's sales were $2 million, the estimated provision is $6,000 ($2 million x 3% x $100). The provision would be updated each period for actual claims and revisions to expected future claims.

Legal Dispute Provisions: An IAS 37 Perspective

Under IAS 37, companies recognize provisions when there is a present obligation from legal actions, and future cash outflows are probable. For pending or threatened litigation, companies estimate provisions based on:

• The nature and facts of each dispute
• Opinions of legal counsel
• Prior experience with similar cases

For example, if a legal expert estimates a 40% probability of losing a $250,000 lawsuit, the company would recognize a $100,000 provision ($250,000 x 40%) on its books. The provision would be reassessed each period as new information emerges.

Environmental Restoration Provisions: Accounting Considerations

Under IAS 37, provisions must be made for estimated environmental restoration costs if companies have an obligation to remedy environmental damage. Key factors in estimating provisions include:

• Surveys of areas needing restoration
• Applicable technologies and costs
• Timing of restoration work

For example, if an oil company estimates it will cost $5 million in 5 years to clean up a site, it would record a $3.1 million provision now ($5 million discounted at 10% for 5 years). The provision would be increased over time to reflect the impact of discounting until the restoration work occurs.

Restructuring Provisions: Criteria and Measurement

According to IAS 37, companies can only recognize restructuring provisions once a detailed plan has been approved and communicated. Key aspects include:

• Location, function, approximate number of employees impacted
• Expenditures involved
• Timing of implementation

For example, if a company plans to close a factory in 6 months, affecting 50 employees at a total cost of $1.5 million, it would recognize the full $1.5 million provision immediately upon approving and announcing the plan.

Disclosures for Contingencies and Provisions

This section outlines disclosure requirements for contingencies and provisions under IAS 37.

Contingent Liability Disclosures: What You Need to Know

Under IAS 37, companies must disclose details regarding contingent liabilities in the financial statements. This includes a brief description of the nature of the contingent liability and, where practical, an estimate of the potential financial impact.

Key disclosures for unrecognized contingent liabilities should cover:

• The uncertainties that exist
• Any pending legal cases or claims
• An estimate of the potential outflow of resources, if possible

For example, if a company is involved in a lawsuit but has not recognized a provision because they believe the claim is unlikely to succeed, they would still need to disclose details of the case as an unrecognized contingent liability.

Making these disclosures provides useful information to financial statement users for assessing the company's risks and potential cash outflows. The disclosures should be clear, concise, and help readers understand the magnitude of exposure.

Provision Disclosures: Ensuring Transparency

For recognized provisions under IAS 37, robust disclosures are also essential for transparency. Key areas to cover include:

• A breakdown of the movements in provisions during the period, typically shown in a rollforward schedule
• Qualitative descriptions of the nature and uncertainties related to significant provisions
• Key assumptions made in estimating provisions, as well as a sensitivity analysis

The rollforward schedule reconciles the beginning and ending provision balances, outlining additions, reversals, uses of provisions, and other adjustments made. This quantitative disclosure provides readers with greater insight into the judgment involved with provisions.

Discussing the assumptions and uncertainties behind major provisions also enables users to better grasp the reliability of these estimates. Sensitivity analysis further allows readers to understand how changes in assumptions could materially impact the financial statements.

Overall, proper disclosures around contingencies and provisions are vital for compliance with accounting standards and providing transparency to readers. Both quantitative and qualitative information should be included to aid in understanding and decision-making.

Summary and Key Takeaways

To conclude, we will recap the major concepts around accounting for contingencies and provisions under IAS 37.

Revisiting Recognition Criteria for IAS 37

IAS 37 has specific recognition criteria that must be met before a contingent liability or asset can be recognized on the balance sheet. The key thresholds are:

• A present obligation arising from a past event that will likely require an outflow of resources
• A probable outflow of economic resources. "Probable" means more likely than not to occur
• A reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation

If these criteria are met, the contingency should be recognized on the balance sheet as a provision.

Measurement Approaches: A Summary

There are a few common methods to measure provisions under IAS 37:

• Expected value - Weighted average of all possible outcomes
• Most likely amount - Single most likely payout
• Range of outcomes - Best case and worst case estimates

The estimated amount should be the risk-adjusted present value of the expected cash outflows.

Disclosure Checklist for Contingencies and Provisions

Relevant IAS 37 disclosures include:

• The nature, timing, and uncertainties related to the obligation
• Major assumptions made concerning future events
• The amount of any expected reimbursement stating the amount of any asset recognized
• An indication of the uncertainties relating to the amount or timing of outflows
• The possibility of any reimbursement

Following these disclosure requirements allows financial statement users to fully understand the company's contingent liabilities and provisions.

Related posts

• Investment Property: Recognition and Measurement
• Long-Lived Assets: Impairment Testing and Recognition
• Intangible Assets: Recognition and Amortization Rules
• Lease Accounting: Lessor Accounting Practices